Home • Chronicles • Biography • Publications • Gallery • News • Contact

The Saga of Marjorie McNulty

Kollenborn Chronicles Menu | [Back] [Next]

By Tom Kollenborn © 09/15/2008 | AJNews.com

A cold, dreary Chicago winter day in the late 1880s brought bad news to Marjorie McNulty. Her physician had just diagnosed her lung ailment as tuberculosis. He recommended Marjorie move immediately to the hot and dry desert of Arizona Territory. Believing there was little hope, Marjorie prepared for her trip to the Southwest.

In those days very few people recovered and survived from this dreaded lung disease. Those who contracted tuberculosis were sent to “lunger” (sic) camps in Arizona, New Mexico, Texas and southern California, but few ever left these camps alive. Some camps were prisons without bars and members of these camps were social outcasts. Conditions in these camps were often severe.

Miss McNulty arrived in Arizona Territory on January 11, 1893. She reported to a camp just northeast of Phoenix, where Scottsdale is located today. Marjorie’s residence in this camp had been pre-arranged by her father and physician. For the most part they planned on Marjorie spending the rest of her life there. However, this was not her desire. Tuberculosis or not, she did not plan to just lie down and die.

After several months of basking in the hot rays of the Arizona sun, Marjorie’s condition improved and her strength began to return. It wasn’t too long before she was on her feet and moving about the camp. The camp physician allowed her privileges other camp residents or patients were not permitted. One of these privileges was riding one of the team horses into the desert on the weekends. By the end of October 1898, Marjorie knew her health had returned and she even doubted the diagnosis of her physician in Chicago. She also realized the camp physician had no intention of releasing her— healthy or not.

By December 1898, Marjorie had become an assistant nurse to the camp physician and at this point she realized she would be working in the camp for the rest of her life. She felt like a prisoner. While riding east of the camp one Sunday Marjorie came up on an old Mexican wood cutter. During their conversation, he told her about an Indian medicine man that could cure all diseases that afflicted man or beast. Marjorie took this information with a grain of salt, but expressed an interest. The old Mexican wood cutter gave her directions how to find the old Indian Medicine man and his camp near Superstition Mountain. Marjorie looked east toward Superstition Mountain looming on the horizon.

Marjorie carefully planned her departure from the “lunger” camp on March 3, 1899. She planned on seeking refuge in the Superstition Mountains and never returning to the camp. She rode away from the camp late in the evening meaning to never return again. She would be searching Superstition Mountain for the medicine man known as Makai.

As she made her way across the desert, dark clouds gathered overhead. When she neared the site of Jim Bark’s line camp on the northwest edge of Superstition Mountain, she turned south following a canyon. On the distant horizon she could see a needle-shaped peak. It was near here she had been told by the Mexican woodcutter she could find the old Indian medicine man.

“You will spot the smoke of his camp without any problem,” she was told.

By evening of the next day she had reached her destination. Her energy had been sapped by the long ride. She tied her horse to a tree for the night. Locating a small cave she decided to spent the night and search for Makai the next day.

It rained all night and by morning Marjorie was cold and weak. As she peered from the entrance of the cave she could see her horse was gone. During the night he had broken away and probably returned to the “lunger” camp.

After this long ordeal she was hungry, weak, and cold. Sensing her situation as hopeless, she closed her eyes and drifted off to sleep. Only by chance was her sleep interrupted by a barking dog.

Opening her eyes, she could see a dog and an old Indian standing in the entrance of the small cave. At first he did not speak, but in his eyes she could see concern and compassion. This was Marjorie’s first meeting with Makai and many years later she wrote the following narrative:

“His hair was silver-grey and long, very coarse. His hands were calloused and his skin was wrinkled. He stood just five foot in height and somewhat bent forward. He wore nothing more than a loin cloth and some kind of a fur blanket for protection against the early morning cold. He carried three bags around his waist, colorfully painted. On his feet he wore deerskin moccasins. On his right side he carried a beautifully ornamented knife. He spoke with broken English  extremely difficult to understand at first.”

Marjorie further wrote, “When I realized I was plucked from the jaws of death, a surge of new energy returned to my body. Slowly we conversed and I tried to explain why I was seeking his help. He told me to lie and rest, he would soon return for me. The old medicine man commanded his dog to stay with me.

Soon he returned with some small branches and twigs to build a fire. He then heated a small bowl of herb broth that soon began to steam. When the broth was warm he had me drink it. As we sat and struggled to communicate with each other, my strength began to return. He asked me to follow him to his camp. He said I would be safe there and welcome for as long as I wanted to stay.”

She continued, “Makai’s camp was located in a small canyon just west of Weaver’s Needle. The old man lived in a cave and part of a brush lean-to. He had water stored in goat-skin bags hanging from a Mesquite tree branch. As I looked the camp over I couldn’t imagine myself living here the rest of my life, but anything was better than the lunger camp.

“After a couple of weeks I made a choice to remain with Makai and his wilderness homeland. The freedom of the mountains was far better than the isolation of the camp. I roamed the Superstitions with Makai, enjoying every minute of it. I would have remained his disciple forever, but on the morning of December 10, 1900, I tried to wake Makai and I found that his spirit had left his body. He was dead!”

It was January 1901 before Marjorie McNulty finally made her way back to Chicago. She married a young mining engineer in 1906 and moved to South Africa. Marjorie had found her health in the Superstition Mountains of Arizona with the guidance of Makai. He had helped return her to a productive life.

Marjorie McNulty passed away in 1954 leaving behind a legacy on the Superstition Mountains in the form of a diary. Her story is another of the endless tales about the Superstition Wilderness Area.

*****

[Home] [Chronicles] [Biography] [Publications] [Gallery] [News] [Contact]

© 2007-2010 Thomas J. Kollenborn | All Rights Reserved | Website sponsored by: www.ApacheTrail.net